Why Is Pumpkin Spice So Popular?
UT marketing professor Raji Srinivasan explains how memories, rituals and a limited-time appeal keep us coming back for a taste of fall.

Photo by Bailey Evertson.
In Austin, fall sometimes arrives on the menu before it arrives in the weather. The air conditioning is still running and shorts remain in rotation while pumpkin spice has already found its way onto cafe menus and grocery store shelves.
“You’re seeing it in lattes, pies, cookies and even protein powders,” said Raji Srinivasan, a marketing professor at The University of Texas at Austin’s McCombs School of Business. Srinivasan studies marketing strategy and new product development. For her, the flavor’s seasonal takeover offers an example of a familiar marketing strategy in every sip, one that makes the feeling of fall part of the purchase.
Srinivasan notes that the appeal of pumpkin spice begins with nostalgia. Its familiar scent can give an everyday purchase a personal connection. “You’re thinking back to the good times you had in your mom’s home or with your grandmother,” Srinivasan said. Those associations can turn a seasonal drink into what she calls “a little time machine in your coffee cup.” Who wouldn’t pay a little extra for such a powerful mood booster?
The anticipation for sweater weather adds another layer to the infatuation. The return of pumpkin spice signals that cooler days and familiar celebrations are approaching, even if the forecast suggests otherwise. “There’s research to show that anticipation brings up enjoyment,” Srinivasan said. She compares it with planning a vacation. A trip might last only a few days, but the excitement can begin months before departure. Waiting for a favorite seasonal flavor can offer a similar pleasure.
Ritual also contributes to the appeal of pumpkin spice. Ordering that first latte can become an annual way to welcome fall, much as a morning routine helps set the tone for the day. “Even doing a small ritual,” Srinivasan said, “like having that pumpkin spice latte when it comes in, can become part of the enjoyment.”
Limited availability not only gives shoppers another reason to buy but also creates a sense of urgency that businesses can use to their advantage. Knowing a seasonal favorite will soon leave the menu creates a fear of missing out, encouraging consumers to order while they still can. For businesses, this sense of urgency presents an opportunity to stand out from the competition. Launching early gives a brand a chance to be a pioneer, capturing customers’ attention before competitors while extending its selling season. However, the perfect timing requires a balance. If the seasonal flavor stays on the menu too long, Srinivasan cautioned, it could lose the limited-time appeal that makes customers eager for its return.
Ultimately, pumpkin spice’s popularity comes from giving customers more than something to eat or drink. It can bring back a favorite memory, mark the start of a tradition or offer an early taste of the season ahead. In Austin, that last promise can be especially welcome. “It gives us almost the sense that fall is coming,” Srinivasan said, “even though we’re still wearing our shorts.”



